Here's the list of 25 players. Since we missed two seasons between our first All-Decade team (after the first 10 years of D3hoops.com) and the beginning of the decade, we chose to consider anyone who played at the Division III level at any point from the beginning of the 2009-10 season through the end of the 2019-20 season. And of those players, we considered their entire career.
- First All-Decade team (1997-98 season through 2006-07 season)
Each player has a profile page, which you can click through to below.
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | School | Profile | All-American Selections |
| G | Sydney Moss | Thomas More | Click here | 2014*, 2015*, 2016* |
| G | Chelsie Schweers | Christopher Newport | Click here | 2008 ($), 2010 (1st), 2011* |
| F | Madison Temple | Thomas More | Click here | 2018 (1st), 2019* |
| F | Melissa Tobie | Montclair State | Click here | 2013, 2014 (1st), 2015 (1st) |
| C | Carissa (Verkaik) Ratliff | Calvin | Click here | 2010 ($), 2011 (1st), 2012 (1st), 2013* |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Profile | All-American Selections |
| G | Brandi Dawson | Trine | Click here | 2017, 2018, 2019 (1st) |
| G | Katie (McDaniels) Peltz | Wheaton (Ill.) | Click here | 2016 (1st), 2017 (1st) |
| G | Caroline Stedman | Amherst | Click here | 2010, 2012 (1st) |
| C | Carrie Snikkers | Hope | Click here | 2009, 2010**, 2011 |
| C | Kaitlin (Langer) Simmet | St. Thomas | Click here | 2016 (1st), 2017* |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Profile | All-American Selections |
| G | Abby Owings | Thomas More | Click here | 2016, 2017 (1st), 2018 |
| G | Lauren (Avant) Sumski | Rhodes | Click here | 2013 (1st), 2014 (1st) |
| G/F | Jaclyn Daigneault | Amherst | Click here | 2009, 2011 (1st) |
| F | Alexandra Leslie | Rochester | Click here | 2015 ($), 2016 (1st), 2017, 2018 |
| F | Lisa Murphy | Carnegie Mellon | Click here | 2016 (1st), 2017 (1st) |
| Fourth team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Profile | All-American selections |
| G | Sam Barber | UW-Stevens Point | Click here | 2012, 2013 (1st) |
| G | Heather Johns | Whitman | Click here | 2014 (1st), 2015 |
| F | Kyra Dayon | FDU-Florham | Click here | 2013, 2014 (1st) |
| F/C | Nicole Wurdeman | Babson | Click here | 2010, 2011, 2012 |
| C | Hannah (Munger) Williams | George Fox | Click here | 2011 (1st), 2012 |
| Honorable mention | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Profile | All-American selections |
| G | Ali Doswell | Amherst | Click here | 2016, 2017 (1st) |
| G | Olivia Lett | Illinois Wesleyan | Click here | 2012* |
| G | Katie Sire | Montclair State | Click here | 2017, 2018 (1st) |
| F | Hannah Frazier | Wheaton (Ill.) | Click here | 2019 (1st), 2020 |
| C | Hannah Spaulding | St. Thomas | Click here | 2018, 2019 (1st) |
* National Player of the Year
$ National Rookie of the Year
1st denotes First-team All-American selection