Photos by d3photography.com and Carthage athletics
Here's the list of 25 players. Since we bypassed two seasons between our first All-Decade team (after the first 10 years of D3hoops.com) and the beginning of the decade, we chose to consider anyone who played primarily at the Division III level at any point from the beginning of the 2009-10 season through the end of the 2019-20 season -- anyone who played in the decade. And of those players, we considered their entire career.
- First All-Decade team (1997-98 season through 2006-07 season)
Each player has a profile page, which you can view through the links below.
| First team | ||||
| Pos. | Player | School | Profile | All-American Selections |
| G | Nate Axelrod | Ohio Wesleyan | Click here | 2015 ($), 2016, 2017, 2018* |
| G | Steve Djurickovic | Carthage | Click here | 2008 ($), 2009, 2010*, 2011 (1st) |
| G | Aston Francis | Wheaton (Ill.) | Click here | 2018, 2019* |
| G | Aaron Toomey | Amherst | Click here | 2012, 2013 (1st), 2014* |
| F | Joey Flannery | Babson | Click here | 2015 (1st), 2016 (1st), 2017* |
| Second team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Profile | All-American Selections |
| G | John DiBartolomeo | Rochester | Click here | 2013* |
| G | Jake Ross | Springfield | Click here | 2017 ($), 2018, 2019, 2020 (1st) |
| G | Sean Wallis | Washington U. | Click here | 2009, 2010 (1st) |
| F | Aaron Walton-Moss | Cabrini | Click here | 2012 ($), 2013, 2014 (1st), 2015 (1st) |
| C | Michael Mayer | Williams | Click here | 2013, 2014 (1st) |
| Third team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Profile | All-American Selections |
| G | Hunter Hill | Augustana | Click here | 2015, 2016 (1st) |
| G | Ty Sabin | Ripon | Click here | 2015, 2016, 2017 (1st) |
| G | DJ Woodmore | Virginia Wesleyan | Click here | 2011 ($), 2012, 2014 |
| F | Tim McCrary | Wheaton (Ill.) | Click here | 2010, 2011, 2012 (1st) |
| F | Connor Raridon | North Central (Ill.) | Click here | 2019, 2020 (1st) |
| Fourth team | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Profile | All-American selections |
| G | Booker Coplin | Augsburg | Click here | 2019, 2020 |
| G | Ian Franks | Wooster | Click here | 2010, 2011 (1st) |
| G | Nate West | LeTourneau | Click here | 2020 * |
| F | Ryan Sharry | Middlebury | Click here | 2011, 2012 (1st) |
| C | Jack Flynn | UW-Oshkosh | Click here | 2019, 2020 |
| Honorable mention | ||||
| Pos | Player | School | Profile | All-American selections |
| G | Lamonte Thomas | Johnson & Wales | Click here | 2011, 2012 |
| F | Chris Davis | UW-Whitewater | Click here | 2012* |
| F | Jared Suderley | Hartwick | Click here | 2012, 2014 (1st) |
| F | Ryan Garver | Nebraska Wesleyan | Click here | 2018, 2019 (1st) |
| C | AJ Matthews | Farmingdale State | Click here | 2012, 2013 (1st) |
* D3hoops.com National Player of the Year
$ D3hoops.com National Rookie of the Year
1st denotes first-team All-American selection