| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Adam Dauksas | Jr. | Illinois Wesleyan |
Homewood, Ill. |
| G | Nick Bennett | Sr. | UW-Stevens Point | Stevens Point, Wis. |
| F | Jason Kalsow | Sr. | UW-Stevens Point |
Hunley, Ill. |
| F | Seth Hauben | Sr. | Rochester | Newton, Mass. |
| C | Shacun Malave | Sr. | New York City Tech | Bronx, N.Y. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Cedric Isom | Jr. | East Texas Baptist |
Newton, Texas |
| G | Keelan Amelianovich | Jr. | Illinois Wesleyan |
Naperville, Ill. |
| F | Travis DePree | Sr. | Albion | Holland, Mich. |
| F | Thad Davis | Sr. | Baldwin-Wallace | Elyria, Ohio |
| C | Tommy Stolhandske | Sr. | Texas Lutheran | San Antonio, Texas |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Amin Wright | Sr. | Ramapo | Jersey City, N.J. |
| G | J.D. Byers | Sr. | Lebanon Valley | Westminster, Md. |
| F | Justin Wansley | Jr. | Randolph-Macon | Richmond, Va. |
| F | Jarrett Kearse | Sr. | Lincoln |
Philadelphia, Pa. |
| C | Badou Gaye | Sr. | Gwynedd-Mercy |
Norristown, Pa. |
| Fourth Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Nick Pelotte | Sr. | Plymouth State | Bingham, Maine |
| G | Mike McGarvey | Jr. | Ursinus |
Lower Gwynedd, Pa. |
| F | Chris Braier |
Jr. | Lawrence |
Wauwatosa, Wis. |
| F | Chris Martin | Sr. | Elmhurst | Eureka, Ill. |
| C | Josh Hinz | Jr. | Beloit | Fort Atkinson, Wis. |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Kyle Myrick | Jr. | Lincoln | Philadelphia, Pa. |
| G | Tommy Becker |
Sr. | Ripon | Delavan, Wis. |
| F | Russ Churchwell | Sr. | Oglethorpe |
Loganville, Ga. |
| F | Michael Reich | Sr. | Colorado College | Rolling Hills, Calif. |
| F | Ifesinachi Anosike | Sr. | Salem State | Staten Island,
N.Y. |