| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Korey Coon | Sr. | Illinois Wesleyan | East Peoria, Ill. |
| G | Merrill Brunson | Sr. | UW-Platteville | Richland Center, Wis. |
| F | Aaron Winkle | Sr. | Calvin | Lake City, Mich. |
| F | Brant Bailey | Sr. | UW-Stevens Point | Wisconsin Dells, Wis. |
| C | Jon Wallenfelsz | Sr. | UW-Eau Claire | Mosinee, Wis. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Horace Jenkins | Jr. | William Paterson | Elizabeth, N.J. |
| G | T.J. Grimes | Sr. | Hampden-Sydney | Onancock, Va. |
| F | Chad Kahle | Sr. | Defiance | Defiance, Ohio |
| F | Antoine Sinclair | Jr. | Christopher Newport | Hampton, Va. |
| C | Mo Davis | Sr. | Rowan | Glassboro, N.J. |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Pat Britton | Sr. | Ithaca | Carthage, N.Y. |
| G | Josh Estelle | Sr. | Wabash | New Castle, Ind. |
| F | Sherm Carstensen | Jr. | UW-Eau Claire | Eau Claire, Wis. |
| F | Alex Kraft | So. | Franklin & Marshall | Lansdale, Pa. |
| C | Jason Wiertel | So. | Carthage | Buffalo Grove, Ill. |
| Fourth Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Kareem Tatum | Jr. | Connecticut College | Worcester, Mass. |
| G | Daniel Martinez | Sr. | McMurry | El Paso, Texas |
| F | Elliott Broadnax | Sr. | Colorado College | Colorado Springs, Colo. |
| F | Ken Allen | Sr. | Colby | Monson, Maine |
| C | Greg Hardin | Jr. | Hunter | Far Rockaway, N.Y. |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Rob Pisanelli | Sr. | Hobart | Poughkeepsie, N.Y. |
| G | Pat Maloney | Jr. | Catholic | Brant Beach, N.J. |
| F | Jeremy Veenstra | Fr. | Calvin | Kalamazoo, Mich. |
| F | Jaron Warner | Sr. | Clarke | Marrero, La. |
| C | Jeff Gibbs | So. | Otterbein | Columbus, Ohio |