Coach of the Year: David Hixon, Amherst
Player of the Year: Ben Strong, Guilford
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Andrew Olson | Jr. | Amherst | San Diego, Calif. |
| G | Mike Hoyt | Sr. | Mount St. Mary | Florida, N.Y. |
| F | Tori Davis | Sr. | Baldwin-Wallace | Elyria, Ohio |
| F | Zach Freeman | Sr. | Illinois Wesleyan | Bloomington, Ill. |
| C | Ben Strong | Jr. | Guilford | Chapel Hill, N.C. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | James Cooper | Jr. | Wooster | Springfield, Ohio |
| G | Amir Mazarei | Sr. | Redlands | Thousand Oaks, Calif. |
| F | Brandon Adair | Sr. | Virginia Wesleyan | Virginia Beach, Va. |
| F | Tom Port | Sr. | Wooster | Avon Lake, Ohio |
| C | Isaac Rosefelt | Sr. | St. Thomas | St. Paul, Minn. |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Ryan Cain | Sr. | WPI | Webster, Mass. |
| G | Nate Drury | Sr. | Carroll | Littleton, Colo. |
| F | Larry Welton | Jr. | Aurora | Chicago, Ill. |
| F | Dane Borchers | Sr. | Wittenberg | Russia, Ohio |
| C | Jason Boone | Sr. | New York University | Sugar Loaf, N.Y. |
| Fourth Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | D.J. Jones | Sr. | Mississippi College | Vicksburg, Miss. |
| G | Stephen Cramer | Sr. | Hope | Akron, Mich. |
| F | Eric Downie | Sr. | Salem State | Medford, Mass. |
| F | Joe Werner | Sr. | UW-La Crosse | Chippewa Falls, Wis. |
| C | Tyler Ousley | Sr. | Otterbein | Butler, Ohio |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Bryan Schnettler | Sr. | St. Thomas | Sartell, Minn. |
| G | Sherod Harris | Jr. | Brockport State | Rochester, N.Y. |
| F | Matt Griffin | Sr. | Johns Hopkins | Glen Mills, Pa. |
| F | Chad McGowan | Jr. | York (Pa.) | Dallastown, Pa. |
| F | Troy Ruths | Jr. | Washington U. | Sugar Land, Texas |