| Date | Away | Home | Time/Status | Links | |||
| Nov. 13 | D'Youville | 81 | Nazareth | 91 | Final | RC | |
| @ Nazareth College | |||||||
| Nov. 14 | Alfred State | 77 | D'Youville | 93 | Final | ||
| @ Nazareth College | |||||||
| Grove City | 78 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 57 | Final | |||
| SUNY Geneseo | 89 | Medaille | 85 | Final | |||
| Geneva | 75 | Hilbert | 102 | Final | |||
| Nov. 16 | La Roche | 65 | Longwood | 89 | Final | ||
| Frostburg State | 86 | Mount Aloysius | 92 | Final - OT | |||
| Nov. 17 | Alfred State | 75 | Pitt-Bradford | 87 | Final | ||
| Hilbert | 94 | Houghton | 91 | Final | |||
| Nov. 18 | Grove City | 73 | Pitt-Greensburg | 79 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Behrend | 75 | Thiel | 56 | Final | |||
| Nov. 20 | St. Lawrence | 71 | Medaille | 77 | Final | ||
| WNY Knee and Orthopedic Surgery Tournament | |||||||
| Penn State-Altoona | 90 | Mount Aloysius | 80 | Final | |||
| Coaches vs. Cancer Tournament @ Juniata College | |||||||
| La Roche | 65 | Catholic | 84 | Final | |||
| @ 45th Annual Marietta Shrine Tournament - Marietta, Ohio | |||||||
| Pitt-Bradford | 69 | Gettysburg | 73 | Final | |||
| Gettysburg Tip-Off Tournament First Round | |||||||
| Chatham | 67 | Hilbert | 98 | Final | |||
| D'Youville | 82 | Rochester Tech | 98 | Final | |||
| @ RIT | |||||||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 65 | McDaniel | 77 | Final | |||
| Coaches vs. Cancer Tournament @ York, Pa. | |||||||
| Nov. 21 | Keuka | 87 | D'Youville | 83 | Final | ||
| Harold J. Brodie Tournament @ RIT | |||||||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 89 | Wilson | 76 | Final | |||
| @ Yes | |||||||
| Washington and Lee | 77 | Pitt-Bradford | 75 | Final | |||
| @ Gettysburg | |||||||
| Mount Aloysius | 81 | Cazenovia | 79 | Final | |||
| Coaches vs. Cancer Tournament @ Juniata | |||||||
| RPI | 71 | Hilbert | 88 | Final | |||
| Hilbert Tip-Off Tournament | |||||||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 60 | Muskingum | 86 | Final | |||
| Baldwin Wallace | 89 | Medaille | 79 | Final | |||
| Penn State-Altoona | 57 | Juniata | 87 | Final | |||
| Coaches vs. Cancer Tournament | |||||||
| La Roche | 73 | Methodist | 78 | Final | |||
| @ Marietta | |||||||
| Nov. 23 | La Roche | 66 | Thiel | 81 | Final | RC | |
| Nov. 24 | Alfred State | 73 | D'Youville | 80 | Final | ||
| Fredonia | 50 | Penn State-Behrend | 66 | Final | |||
| Hilbert | 80 | Elmira | 73 | Final | |||
| Nov. 28 | Allegheny | 64 | Penn State-Behrend | 77 | Final | ||
| Alfred | 91 | Hilbert | 74 | Final | RC | ||
| Mount Aloysius | 77 | Goucher | 75 | Final | |||
| Turkey Weekend Tournament @ Salem, Va. | |||||||
| Medaille | 95 | Fredonia | 74 | Final | |||
| John Carroll | 87 | La Roche | 83 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 50 | Shenandoah | 71 | Final | |||
| BB&T Classic | |||||||
| Nov. 29 | Mount Aloysius | 90 | Roanoke | 102 | Final | RC | |
| Turkey Weekend Tournament | |||||||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 61 | Elizabethtown | 73 | Final | RC | ||
| @ Winchester, Va. | |||||||
| D'Youville | 68 | SUNY-Canton | 82 | Final | RC | ||
| Nov. 30 | Penn State-Altoona | 72 | Wilson | 73 | Final | ||
| Dec. 2 | Mount Aloysius | 76 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 78 | Final | RC | |
| La Roche | 72 | Penn State-Altoona | 69 | Final | |||
| Penn State-Behrend | 71 | D'Youville | 60 | Final | |||
| Hilbert | 72 | Medaille | 67 | Final | |||
| Houghton | 90 | Pitt-Bradford | 81 | Final - OT | |||
| Dec. 5 | Mount Aloysius | 58 | Hilbert | 101 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Altoona | 81 | Medaille | 84 | Final | |||
| D'Youville | 95 | Pitt-Greensburg | 101 | Final | |||
| La Roche | 59 | Penn State-Behrend | 57 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 59 | Pitt-Bradford | 83 | Final | |||
| Dec. 9 | Mount Aloysius | 75 | La Roche | 91 | Final | ||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 97 | Penn State-Altoona | 68 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Bradford | 48 | Penn State-Behrend | 78 | Final | |||
| Dec. 12 | Medaille | 74 | Mount Aloysius | 90 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Behrend | 69 | Penn State-Altoona | 68 | Final | |||
| D'Youville | 83 | La Roche | 77 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Bradford | 72 | Pitt-Greensburg | 79 | Final | |||
| Hilbert | 78 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 64 | Final | |||
| Dec. 14 | D'Youville | 73 | Hilbert | 86 | Final | ||
| Dec. 15 | Medaille | 99 | Morrisville State | 107 | Final - OT | ||
| Dec. 16 | Christopher Newport | 93 | Pitt-Greensburg | 74 | Final | ||
| Dec. 17 | Bethany | 88 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 75 | Final | RC | |
| Dec. 18 | Mount Aloysius | 56 | Lancaster Bible | 99 | Final | RC | |
| Dec. 19 | Waynesburg | 88 | Pitt-Greensburg | 97 | Final | ||
| Pitt-Bradford | 51 | Juniata | 63 | Final | |||
| Hiram | 88 | La Roche | 81 | Final | RC | ||
| Dec. 29 | Pitt-Bradford | 59 | Wooster | 79 | Final | ||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 57 | Guilford | 89 | Final | RC | ||
| Dec. 30 | Medaille | 73 | Utica | 76 | Final | ||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 62 | Greensboro | 101 | Final | |||
| @ Guilford College Classic | |||||||
| Mount St. Joseph | 77 | Pitt-Bradford | 61 | Final | |||
| @ Wooster, Ohio | |||||||
| Drew | 89 | Mount Aloysius | 88 | Final | RC | ||
| Jan. 2 | Cortland | 87 | Medaille | 67 | Final | RC | |
| University of Western Ontario | 74 | D'Youville | 52 | Final | |||
| Case Western Reserve | 77 | Penn State-Behrend | 99 | Final | |||
| Jan. 4 | Carnegie Mellon | 81 | La Roche | 54 | Final | ||
| Jan. 6 | Penn State-Altoona | 75 | Mount Aloysius | 83 | Final | ||
| Medaille | 96 | D'Youville | 84 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 92 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 73 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Bradford | 89 | Hilbert | 101 | Final | |||
| Penn State-Behrend | 76 | Carnegie Mellon | 71 | Final | |||
| Jan. 9 | Mount Aloysius | 73 | D'Youville | 79 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Altoona | 82 | Pitt-Bradford | 97 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 81 | Medaille | 57 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 42 | Penn State-Behrend | 68 | Final | |||
| La Roche | 82 | Hilbert | 95 | Final | |||
| Jan. 10 | Mount Aloysius | 79 | Pitt-Bradford | 86 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Altoona | 67 | Hilbert | 66 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 79 | Penn State-Behrend | 87 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 74 | D'Youville | 92 | Final | |||
| La Roche | 68 | Medaille | 51 | Final | |||
| Jan. 13 | Alfred State | 61 | Hilbert | 81 | Final | ||
| La Roche | 81 | Pitt-Greensburg | 98 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 68 | Penn State-Altoona | 83 | Final | |||
| Medaille | 50 | Penn State-Behrend | 73 | Final | |||
| Jan. 14 | D'Youville | 62 | Pitt-Bradford | 77 | Final | ||
| Jan. 16 | Penn State-Behrend | 81 | Mount Aloysius | 62 | Final | ||
| D'Youville | 93 | Penn State-Altoona | 87 | Final | |||
| Hilbert | 101 | Pitt-Greensburg | 87 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 72 | Medaille | 95 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Bradford | 70 | La Roche | 73 | Final | |||
| Jan. 18 | Mount Aloysius | 80 | Pitt-Greensburg | 84 | Final | ||
| Hilbert | 58 | Penn State-Behrend | 69 | Final | |||
| La Roche | 101 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 85 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Bradford | 66 | Medaille | 77 | Final | |||
| Jan. 20 | Lycoming | 71 | Penn State-Altoona | 54 | Final | ||
| Jan. 21 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 65 | Mount Aloysius | 82 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Altoona | 56 | La Roche | 61 | Final | |||
| D'Youville | 47 | Penn State-Behrend | 69 | Final | |||
| Medaille | 84 | Hilbert | 77 | Final | |||
| Jan. 23 | Pitt-Greensburg | 95 | D'Youville | 91 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Behrend | 71 | La Roche | 59 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Bradford | 73 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 57 | Final | |||
| Jan. 24 | Hilbert | 101 | Mount Aloysius | 76 | Final | ||
| Medaille | 72 | Penn State-Altoona | 86 | Final | |||
| Jan. 27 | La Roche | 86 | Mount Aloysius | 76 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Altoona | 72 | Pitt-Greensburg | 82 | Final | |||
| Penn State-Behrend | 74 | Pitt-Bradford | 58 | Final | |||
| Hilbert | 93 | D'Youville | 83 | Final | |||
| Alfred State | 81 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 71 | Final - OT | |||
| Jan. 30 | Mount Aloysius | 80 | Medaille | 83 | Final | ||
| La Roche | 68 | D'Youville | 67 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 75 | Pitt-Bradford | 82 | Final | |||
| Penn State-Altoona | 44 | Penn State-Behrend | 71 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 66 | Hilbert | 108 | Final | |||
| Feb. 3 | Mount Aloysius | 95 | Penn State-Altoona | 107 | Final - OT | ||
| D'Youville | 68 | Medaille | 90 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 97 | Pitt-Greensburg | 108 | Final | |||
| Hilbert | 76 | Pitt-Bradford | 68 | Final | |||
| Alfred State | 45 | Penn State-Behrend | 81 | Final | |||
| Feb. 6 | D'Youville | 91 | Mount Aloysius | 83 | Final | ||
| Pitt-Bradford | 74 | Penn State-Altoona | 85 | Final | |||
| Penn State-Behrend | 85 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 48 | Final | |||
| Hilbert | 91 | La Roche | 77 | Final | |||
| Medaille | 69 | Pitt-Greensburg | 75 | Final | |||
| @ Seton Hill University | |||||||
| Feb. 10 | Penn State-Altoona | 76 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 62 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Behrend | 52 | Medaille | 71 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 71 | La Roche | 84 | Final | |||
| Pitt-Bradford | 85 | D'Youville | 75 | Final | |||
| Gold Game | |||||||
| Feb. 13 | Pitt-Greensburg | 82 | Hilbert | 101 | Final | ||
| Mount Aloysius | 76 | Penn State-Behrend | 87 | Final | |||
| Medaille | 91 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 75 | Final | |||
| La Roche | 67 | Pitt-Bradford | 68 | Final | |||
| Feb. 14 | Penn State-Altoona | 82 | D'Youville | 85 | Final | ||
| Senior Night | |||||||
| Feb. 17 | Pitt-Greensburg | 90 | Mount Aloysius | 87 | Final | ||
| Penn State-Behrend | 59 | Hilbert | 63 | Final | |||
| Franciscan (Ohio) | 77 | La Roche | 82 | Final | |||
| Medaille | 78 | Pitt-Bradford | 85 | Final | |||
| D'Youville | 96 | Houghton | 100 | Final | |||
| Feb. 20 | Pitt-Bradford | 91 | Mount Aloysius | 80 | Final | ||
| Hilbert | 83 | Penn State-Altoona | 74 | Final | |||
| D'Youville | 84 | Franciscan (Ohio) | 70 | Final | |||
| Medaille | 78 | La Roche | 82 | Final | |||
| Penn State-Behrend | 72 | Pitt-Greensburg | 77 | Final | |||
| at Mt. Aloysius @ Cresson, Pa. | |||||||
| Feb. 24 | Medaille | 66 | Pitt-Greensburg | 80 | Final | ||
| AMCC first round @ Penn State-Fayette | |||||||
| Pitt-Bradford | 67 | La Roche | 61 | Final | |||
| AMCC Tournament Quarterfinal | |||||||
| Feb. 27 | Pitt-Bradford | 75 | Hilbert | 80 | Final | ||
| AMCC Semifinal | |||||||
| Pitt-Greensburg | 67 | Penn State-Behrend | 64 | Final - OT | |||
| AMCC Semifinal - Hilbert @ Hamburg, NY | |||||||
| Feb. 28 | Pitt-Greensburg | 76 | Hilbert | 74 | Final | ||
| AMCC Championship Game | |||||||
| Mar. 2 | Grove City | 50 | Penn State-Behrend | 69 | Final | ||
| ECAC South Region Quarterfinals | |||||||
| Mar. 4 | Pitt-Greensburg | 68 | Ohio Wesleyan | 114 | Final | RC | |
| NCAA Div. III Tournament - 1st Round | |||||||
| Mar. 5 | Penn State-Behrend | 72 | Swarthmore | 84 | Final | ||
| ECAC South Region Semifinals @ DeSales University | |||||||