Entering the 1999-2000 season:
| Team (first-place votes) | Votes |
| 1. UW-Platteville (19) | 618 |
| 2. Hampden-Sydney (3) | 542 |
| 3. William Paterson (2) | 527 |
| 4. Wilkes | 505 |
| 5. Franklin and Marshall | 488 |
| 6. Rowan (1) | 475 |
| 7. Connecticut College | 353 |
| 8. Christopher Newport | 336 |
| 9. Cortland State | 328 |
| 10. Ohio Northern | 306 |
| 11. Wooster | 282 |
| 12. Catholic U. | 259 |
| 13. Johns Hopkins | 233 |
| 14. John Carroll | 213 |
| 15. Illinois Wesleyan | 206 |
| 16. Trinity (Conn.) | 176 |
| 17. Manchester | 168 |
| 18. Richard Stockton | 141 |
| 19. UW-Eau Claire | 138 |
| 20. Wheaton (Ill.) | 128 |
| 21. Anderson | 113 |
| 22. Calvin | 110 |
| 23. Augsburg | 108 |
| 24. Rhodes | 107 |
| 25. Bowdoin | 106 |
Others receiving votes: Franklin 80; Defiance 79; St. John Fisher 77; Nebraska Wesleyan 72; Goucher 71; Washington U. (Mo.) 71; UW-Whitewater 60; Otterbein 54; Mississippi College 49; Virginia Wesleyan 43; Upper Iowa 39; Linfield 36; Gustavus Adolphus 35; McMurry 33; Ripon 33; Geneseo State 32; Springfield 23; Albright 23; Williams 23; Maryville (Tenn.) 21; New Jersey City 21; UW-Oshkosh 16; Salem State 14; Nazareth 13; UC San Diego 13; Rose-Hulman 12; Simpson 11; Wittenberg 11; New York University 9; Hamilton 8; Elmira 8; Carthage 7; Muhlenberg 7; RPI 7; Scranton 6; Hope 6; Union 6; Wabash 6; Cabrini 5; Plymouth State 4; Lebanon Valley 2; Pomona-Pitzer 2; St. John's 2; Trinity (Texas) 2; Widener 2; Emory 1; Mount St. Joseph 1; Randolph-Macon 1; Rochester 1; UW-Stevens Point 1.
The D3hoops.com Top 25 is voted on by a panel of 25 coaches, Sports Information Directors and media members from across the country, and is published weekly.