All-time D3hoops.com men's All-Americans

This page lists all of D3hoops.com's postseason All-America selections, including some breakdowns by category.

Player of the Year

Rookie of the Year

The D3hoops.com Player of the Year award began in 2006.
The all-time list:
2006: Kyle Myrick, Lincoln
2007: Ben Strong, Guilford
2008: Troy Ruths, Washington U.
2009: Jimmy Bartolotta, MIT
2010: Steve Djurickovic, Carthage
2011: Michael Taylor, Whitworth
2012: Chris Davis, UW-Whitewater
2013: John DiBartolomeo, Rochester
2014: Aaron Toomey, Amherst
2015: Gerry Wixted, Dickinson
2016: Lucas Johnson, Benedictine
2017: Joey Flannery, Babson 
2018: Nate Axelrod, Ohio Wesleyan
2019: Aston Francis, Wheaton (Ill.)
2020: Nate West, LeTourneau
2021: None selected
2022: Buzz Anthony, Randolph-Macon
2023: Alex Sobel, Middlebury

The D3hoops.com Rookie of the Year award began in 2008, honoring the best freshman in Division III men's and women's basketball. The all-time list:

2008: Steve Djurickovic, Carthage
2009: Justin Hallowell, Wooster
2010: Derek Raridon, North Central (Ill.)
2011: DJ Woodmore, Virginia Wesleyan
2012: Aaron Walton-Moss, Cabrini
2013: Ben Ryan, Augustana
2014: Duncan Robinson, Williams
2015: Nate Axelrod, Ohio Wesleyan
2016: Cam Haslam, Chapman
2017: Jake Ross, Springfield
2018: Spencer Levi, University of Dallas
2019: Anders Nelson, St. Thomas
2020: Vinny DeAngelo, Swarthmore
2021: None selected
2022: John Adams, WPI
2023: Jalen Overway, Calvin

Coach of the Year

2006: David Macedo, Virginia Wesleyan
2007: David Hixon, Amherst
2008: Mark Edwards, Washington U.
2009: Glenn Robinson, Franklin & Marshall
2010: Bob Semling, UW-Stevens Point
2011: Steve Fritz, St. Thomas
2012: Pat Miller, UW-Whitewater
2013: Ken DeWeese, Mary Hardin-Baylor
2014: Pat Miller, UW-Whitewater
2015: Bob Semling, UW-Stevens Point
2016: Keith Bunkenburg, Benedictine
2017: Eric Bridgeland, Whitman; and Grey Giovanine, Augustana
2018: Dale Wellman, Nebraska Wesleyan
2019: Matt Lewis, UW-Oshkosh
2020: Elliot Steinmetz, Yeshiva
2021: None selected
2022: Josh Merkel, Randolph-Macon
2023: Sean Smith, North Park

Four-time All-Americans

 
Jeremy Veenstra
Calvin, Forward

2000, 2001,
2002, 2003 

Steve Djurickovic
Carthage, Guard

2008, 2009,
2010, 2011 

Most all-time selections

 

Illinois Wesleyan 17 (11 players)
Wheaton (Ill.) 14 (eight players)
Williams 12 (nine players)
Washington U. 12 (eight players)
UW-Oshkosh 11 (six players)
Wooster 10 (six players)
Amherst 10 (seven players)
Augustana 10 (six players)
Carthage 9 (three players)
Randolph-Macon 9 (five players)

St. Thomas 8 (seven players)
Middlebury 8 (six players)
UW-Platteville 8 (six players)
Calvin 8 (four players)
Cabrini 7 (four players)
Catholic 7 (four players)
Elmhurst 7 (four players)
Christopher Newport 7 (five players)
Ohio Wesleyan 7 (five players)
Whitworth 7 (six players)
Hope 7 (seven players)
UW-Whitewater 7 (seven players)

All-time All-Americans by school

Albertus Magnus
F Ray Askew, 2012 (2nd)
C Victor Ljuljdjuraj, 2015 (2nd)
F Jaqhawn Walters, 2018 (2nd)
G Darius Watson, 2014 (4th) 

Albion
C Brandon Crawford, 2006 (1st)
F Travis DePree, 2005 (2nd)

Alma
G Scott Nikodemski, 2016 (1st) 

Alvernia
F Terrence Shawell, 2008 (4th)

Amherst
G John Bedford, 2006 (3rd)
F Brian Baskauskas, 2009 (4th)
G Andrew Olson, 2007 (1st), 2008 (1st)
F Andrew Schiel, 2004 (HM)
G Aaron Toomey, 2012 (HM), 2013 (1st), 2014 (1st, Player of the Year)
F Willy Workman, 2013 (3rd)
F Steve Zieja, 2003 (HM)

Anderson
C Chaz Smoot, 1999 (1st)

Augsburg
G Booker Coplin, 2019 (2nd), 2020 (HM)
F Devean George, 1998 (2nd), 1999 (1st)
C Dan Kornbaum, 2014 (2nd) 
F Collin Olmscheid, 2018 (1st)

Augustana
G Drew Carstens, 2002 (4th), 2003 (1st), 2004 (3rd)
G Nolan Ebel, 2018 (4th), 2019 (2nd)
G Rick Harrigan, 2006 (2nd)
G Hunter Hill, 2015 (2nd), 2016 (1st)
G Chrishawn Orange, 2017 (4th)
F Ben Ryan, 2016 (2nd) 

Aurora
F Jason Buckley, 1998 (HM)
G Marcus Myers, 2018 (3rd)
F Larry Welton, 2006 (HM), 2007 (3rd), 2008 (2nd)

Austin
G Christian Morgia, 1999 (HM)

Averett
F DeMarcus Morrison, 1998 (2nd)

Babson
F Joey Flannery, 2015 (1st), 2016 (1st), 2017 (1st, Player of the Year)

Baldwin-Wallace
F Thad Davis, 2005 (2nd)
F Tori Davis, 2006 (2nd), 2007 (1st)

Beloit
F Josh Hinz, 2005 (4th), 2006 (4th)

Benedictine
G Tahron Harvey, 2017 (1st)
F Lucas Johnson, 2016 (1st, Player of the Year)

Bethany
C Matt Drahos, 2006 (HM)
F Keith Schubert, 2002 (HM)

Bethel
F Taylor Hall, 2013 (2nd)
G Tim Madson, 2009 (3rd)
F Kyle Zimmermann, 2015 (3rd)

Bowdoin
G Lucas Hausman, 2015 (4th), 2016 (4th)

Brandeis

G Joe Coppens, 2008 (4th)

Bridgewater (Va.)
F Brad Harrington, 1999 (HM)
F Kyle Williford, 2001 (4th), 2002 (1st)

Brockport State
G Sherod Harris, 2007 (HM)
G John Ivy, 2014 (2nd)
F Michael Lofton, 2015 (4th)

Brooklyn
F Richard Jean-Baptiste, 2009 (4th), 2010 (3rd)

Buena Vista
G Adam Jones, 2002 (1st)

Cabrini
G Cory Lemons, 2012 (1st)
F Kevin Misevicius, 2010 (HM)
F Tyheim Monroe, 2017 (4th), 2018 (3rd)
G Aaron Walton-Moss, 2013 (4th), 2014 (1st), 2015 (1st)

Cal Lutheran
C Justin Muth, 2001 (HM)

Calvin
G Jordan Brink, 2015 (1st)
F Derrick DeVries, 2020 (HM)
F Jeremy Veenstra, 2000 (HM), 2001 (4th), 2002 (4th), 2003 (3rd)
F Aaron Winkle, 1999 (3rd), 2000 (1st)

Capital
F Nate Stahl, 2009 (HM)

Carleton
F Jeremy Beckler, 2023 (4th)
F Kevin Grow, 2018 (HM)
F Kent Hanson, 2020 (HM)
F Zach Johnson, 2009 (2nd)

Carroll
G Nate Drury, 2007 (3rd)
G John Hoch, 2010 (3rd)

Carthage
G Steve Djurickovic, 2008 (4th), 2009 (3rd), 2010 (Player of the Year, 1st), 2011 (1st)
G Antoine McDaniel, 2002 (2nd), 2003 (1st)
C Jason Wiertel, 2000 (3rd), 2001 (2nd), 2002 (1st)

Case Western Reserve
G Mitch Prendergast, 2023 (2nd)

Catholic
G Bryson Fonville, 2015 (4th), 2016 (HM)
F Matt Hilleary, 2002 (2nd), 2003 (4th)
C Chris Kearney, 2013 (2nd)
G Pat Maloney, 2000 (HM), 2001 (2nd)

Central
G Miguel Ley, 2010 (HM)

Centre
F Greg Ross, 2012 (4th)

Chicago
G Nate Hainje, 2008 (HM)
C Derek Reich, 2001 (1st), 2002 (2nd), 2003 (1st)

Christopher Newport
F Trey Barber, 2023 (5th)
G Marcus Carter, 2016 (4th), 2019 (HM)
C Terry Gray, 2003 (3rd)
G Jahn Hines, 2023 (4th)
F Antoine Sinclair, 2000 (2nd), 2001 (3rd)

Claremont-Mudd-Scripps
G Josh Angle, 2023 (3rd)
G Tyler Gaffaney, 2015 (2nd)
G Michael Scarlett, 2017 (HM), 2018 (1st)

Clark
G Sean Fleming, 2003 (4th)

Clarke
F Jaron Warner, 2000 (HM)

Colby
F Ken Allen, 2000 (4th)
F Adam Choice, 2009 (4th)
G Sam Jefferson, 2020 (HM)

Colby-Sawyer
F Brian Wilder, 1999 (3rd)

Colorado College
G Verdel Baskin, 1998 (2nd)
F Elliott Broadnax, 2000 (4th)
F Michael Reich, 2005 (HM)

Concordia-Moorhead
F Jordan Bolger, 2016 (4th) 

Concordia (Texas)
F K.B. DeBord, 2002 (2nd)

Connecticut College
G Kareem Tatum, 2000 (4th), 2001 (HM)

Cortland State
G Austin Grunder, 2022 (3rd), 2023 (4th)
G Tom Williams, 2001 (4th)

Defiance
F Chad Kahle, 2000 (2nd)

Delaware Valley
G James Jones, 2011 (HM) 

DeSales
G Darnell Braswell, 2010 (2nd)

Dickinson
G Adam Honig, 2014 (HM)
F Gerry Wixted, 2015 (1st, Player of the Year)

Dubuque
F Andre Norris, 2015 (HM), 2016 (4th)

East Texas Baptist
G Cedric Isom, 2005 (2nd)

Eastern Mennonite
G Todd Phillips, 2010 (1st), 2011 (HM) 

Elizabethtown
F Bob Porambo, 2002 (HM)

Elmhurst
G Ryan Knuppel, 2001 (1st)
F Chris Martin, 2005 (4th), 2006 (3rd)
G Jake Rhode, 2020 (4th), 2022 (2nd)
C Brent Ruch, 2008 (4th), 2009 (2nd)

Emerson
F Rob Hennigan, 2004 (HM)
C Jarred Houston, 2022 (3rd), 2023 (2nd)

Emory
F Jake Davis, 2014 (2nd)
F Alex Foster, 2015 (3rd)
G Matthew Schner, 2022 (1st)

Emory & Henry
G Justin Call, 2004 (2nd)

Farmingdale State
F A.J. Matthews, 2012 (3rd), 2013 (1st)

Ferrum
F Derek Mitchell, 2011 (3rd) 

Fontbonne
F Brian Fogerty, 2009 (HM)

Franklin
G Jason Sibley, 1999 (2nd)

Franklin & Marshall
G Brandon Federici, 2018 (HM)
C Steve Juskin, 2004 (1st)
F Alex Kraft, 2000 (3rd)
F James McNally, 2009 (3rd)
G Georgio Milligan, 2012 (2nd)

Gordon
G Eric Demers, 2020 (HM)

Grinnell

G Steve Wood, 2003 (HM), 2004 (HM)

Guilford
G Matt McCarthy, 2015 (3rd)
C Tyler Sanborn, 2009 (4th), 2010 (1st)
C Ben Strong, 2007 (Player of the Year, 1st), 2008 (1st)

Gustavus Adolphus
G Seth Anderson, 2012 (2nd)
F Tim Brown, 2003 (HM), 2004 (4th)
C Luke Schmidt, 1999 (3rd)

Gwynedd-Mercy
C Badou Gaye, 2004 (HM), 2005 (3rd)

Hamilton
G Kena Gilmour, 2019 (4th)
F Michael Schantz, 1998 (3rd), 1999 (2nd)
F Joe Smith, 2004 (4th)

Hamline
C Carl Hipp, 2011 (3rd) 

Hampden-Sydney
G T.J. Grimes, 2000 (2nd)
G Jeff Monroe, 2003 (2nd), 2004 (1st)

Hanover
G Cam Fails, 2018 (3rd), 2019 (4th)
F Wes McKinney, 2017 (4th) 

Hardin-Simmons
G Matt Addison, 2012 (1st)
F Nathaniel Jack, 2017 (2nd)
F Mardochee Jean, 2008 (3rd)

Hartwick
F Jared Suderley, 2012 (2nd), 2014 (1st)

Hobart
F Richie Bonney, 2014 (3rd)
F Joe Corbett, 2003 (HM)
F Jackson Meshanic, 2023 (3rd)
G Rob Pisanelli, 2000 (HM)
G Stefan Thompson, 2013 (HM) 

Hope
F Harrison Blackledge, 2017 (1st)
G Stephen Cramer, 2007 (4th)
G Joel Holstege, 1998 (1st)
G David Krombeen, 2012 (2nd)
C Don Overbeek, 2003 (2nd)
F Jesse Reimink, 2009 (1st)
F Marcus Vanderheide, 2008 (3rd)

Howard Payne
G Benny West, 2003 (4th), 2004 (3rd)

Hunter
C Greg Hardin, 2000 (4th)

Husson
G Raheem Anderson, 2017 (HM) 

Illinois Wesleyan
F Keelan Amelianovich, 2004 (2nd), 2005 (2nd), 2006 (1st)
G Korey Coon, 1999 (2nd), 2000 (1st)
G Adam Dauksas, 2005 (1st), 2006 (1st)
F Zach Freeman, 2007 (1st)
F Luke Kasten, 2001 (HM), 2003 (3rd)
F Matthew Leritz, 2021 (2nd), 2022 (1st)
F Brent Niebrugge, 1998 (3rd)
G Dylan Overstreet, 2015 (3rd)
G Brady Rose, 2019 (HM)
F Andrew Ziemnik, 2014 (2nd)
G Jordan Zimmer, 2012 (3rd)

Ithaca
G Pat Britton, 2000 (3rd)
G Sean Burton, 2009 (4th)
G Sean Rossi, 2013 (2nd) 

Johns Hopkins
G Conner Delaney, 2020 (3rd), 2022 (5th)
F Matt Griffin, 2007 (HM)

Johnson & Wales
G Quarry Greenaway, 2016 (3rd)
G Lamonte Thomas, 2011 (2nd), 2012 (4th)

Kean
F Jonathan Jones, 2011 (1st) 

Keene State
G Octavio Brito, 2023 (3rd)
F Chris Coates, 2001 (HM)
F Jeff Hunter, 2023 (2nd)
F Tyler Kathan, 2009 (3rd)
F Ty Nichols, 2019 (1st)

King's
G Corey Dickerson, 2001 (4th)

Lasell
C Jose Guitian, 2009 (HM)

Lawrence
F Chris Braier, 2004 (3rd), 2005 (3rd), 2006 (3rd)
G Ryan Kroeger, 2009 (HM)

Lebanon Valley
G J.D. Byers, 2005 (3rd)
F Andy Panko, 1998 (1st), 1999 (1st)

Lehman
C Sekani Francis, 2006 (3rd)

LeTourneau
G Nate West, 2020 (1st, Player of the Year)

Lewis and Clark
G Scott Davis, 2002 (4th)

Lincoln
F Jarrett Kearse, 2005 (3rd)
G Darrel Lewis, 1999 (1st)
G Kyle Myrick, 2005 (HM), 2006 (Player of the Year, 1st)

Linfield
G Dempsey Roggenbuck, 2021 (3rd)

Loras

G Ryan DiCanio, 2019 (4th)
F Kyle White, 2008 (2nd)

Lynchburg
F Alex Graves, 2016 (HM) 

Macalester
F Ben Van Thorre, 2004 (1st)

Manchester
F Antwann Jones, 1999 (1st)

Marietta
F Jesse DuPerow, 2002 (4th)
F A.J. Edwards, 2016 (HM), 2017 (3rd)
G Jason Ellis, 2022 (4th)
G Trevor Halter, 2011 (4th) 
G Lukas Isaly, 2022 (2nd)

Mary Hardin-Baylor
F Kitrick Bell, 2013 (HM)
G Josiah Johnson, 2021 (1st), 2022 (3rd), 2023 (2nd)
F Robert Moore, 2001 (3rd)

Mary Washington
G Greg Rowson, 2023 (5th)

Maryville (Mo.)
G Henry Shannon, 1998 (1st)

Maryville (Tenn.)
C Greg Hernandez, 2010 (3rd)
F Eryk Watson, 2011 (2nd)

Mass-Boston
F Sean Harrington, 1999 (HM)

Mass-Dartmouth
G Marcus Azor, 2022 (2nd)
C Dan Holbrook, 2008 (HM)
G Jordan Rezendes, 2015 (HM), 2016 (2nd)

McMurry
G Alex Denson, 2001 (3rd)
G Daniel Martinez, 2000 (4th)
G Tyerone Washington, 1998 (3rd)

Merchant Marine
G Johnny Garrett, 2001 (3rd)

Middlebury
G Jack Daly, 2018 (4th)
G Joey Kizel, 2013 (HM) 
G Ben Rudin, 2009 (HM)
F Ryan Sharry, 2011 (4th), 2012 (1st)
F Alex Sobel, 2022 (4th), 2023 (1st)
G Matt St. Amour, 2017 (2nd) 

Millsaps
C Edrick Montgomery, 2008 (2nd)

Minnesota-Morris
G CD Douglas, 2018 (4th)

Misericordia
G Willie Chandler, 2001 (HM), 2002 (1st), 2003 (1st)

Mississippi College
G D.J. Jones, 2007 (4th)

MIT
G Jimmy Bartolotta, 2008 (HM), 2009 (1st, Player of the Year)
G Mike D'Auria, 2006 (4th)
F Bradley Jomard, 2019 (4th)
G Mitchell Kates, 2012 (4th)
F Will Tashman, 2013 (2nd) 

Monmouth
F Will Carius, 2019 (3rd)

Montclair State
F Gian Paul Gonzalez, 2006 (4th)

Mount St. Mary
G Mike Hoyt, 2006 (HM), 2007 (1st)

Mount Union
G Nathan Bower-Malone, 2020 (2nd)
G DeAllen Jackson, 2017 (4th)
F Christian Parker, 2023 (1st)

Muhlenberg
C Mark Lesko, 2001 (4th)

Nazareth
G Corey McAdam, 2010 (2nd)
G Zach Wein, 1998 (HM)

Nebraska Wesleyan
F Ryan Garver, 2018 (HM), 2019 (1st)
G Nate Schimonitz, 2020 (1st)

New Jersey City
G Samar Battle, 2004 (4th)
F Sam Toney, 2018 (4th), 2019 (HM)

New York City Tech
C Shacun Malave, 2004 (4th), 2005 (1st)

New York University
C Jason Boone, 2007 (3rd)
G Spencer Freedman, 2023 (3rd)
F Bobby Hawkinson, 2022 (5th)

Nichols
G DeAnte Bruton, 2020 (4th)
G Marcos Echevarria, 2019 (2nd)

North Carolina Wesleyan
G Brandon Givens, 2013 (3rd) 

North Central (Ill.)
F Landon Gamble, 2013 (1st)
G Matt Helwig, 2023 (5th)
F Connor Raridon, 2019 (2nd), 2020 (1st)
F Derek Raridon, 2013 (4th) 
F Alex Sorenson, 2018 (3rd)

North Park
G Juwan Henry, 2016 (HM) 
F Jordan Robinson, 2017 (1st) 

Occidental
G Connor Whitman, 2008 (HM)

Oglethorpe
G Dimetri Chambers, 2022 (4th)
F Russ Churchwell, 2005 (HM)

Ohio Northern
C Ryan Bruns, 2018 (2nd), 2019 (2nd)
G Jim Conrad, 2004 (4th)
F Kyle Meyer, 2010 (HM)
F Kris Oberdick, 2001 (1st)
G Jeremy Thompson, 1998 (HM)

Ohio Wesleyan
G Nate Axelrod, 2016 (2nd), 2017 (2nd), 2018 (Player of the Year, 1st)
G/F Tim Brady, 2012 (4th)
G Jack Clement, 2023 (5th)
F Dustin Rudegeair, 2008 (4th)
G Andy Winters, 2013 (4th) 

Olivet
G Jalen Adams, 2018 (2nd)
C Michael McClary, 2010 (HM), 2011 (2nd)

Oswego State
F Chad Burridge, 2012 (HM)
G Brian Sortino, 2016 (3rd), 2017 (3rd)
F Hayden Ward, 2013 (2nd) 

Otterbein
C Jeff Gibbs, 2000 (HM), 2001 (2nd), 2002 (1st)
C Tyler Ousley, 2007 (4th)

Piedmont
F Jake Baldwin, 2008 (3rd)

Pitt-Bradford
C Matt Beacom, 2002 (HM)

Plattsburgh State
F Jonathan Patron, 2018 (HM)
F Kyle Richardson, 2016 (2nd)
G Anthony Williams, 2008 (2nd)

Plymouth State
G Nick Pelotte, 2005 (4th)

Pomona-Pitzer
G Brendan Mora, 2022 (5th), 2023 (3rd)
G Daniel Rosenbaum, 2019 (3rd)

Puget Sound
G Chase Curtiss, 2006 (4th)
G Matt Glynn, 2004 (HM)

Ramapo
F Thomas Bonacum, 2017 (3rd)
G Charles Ransom, 2003 (3rd)
G Amin Wright, 2005 (3rd)

Randolph
G Colton Hunt, 2013 (1st) 

Randolph-Macon
G Buzz Anthony, 2020 (2nd), 2021 (1st), 2022 (Player of the Year, 1st)
F Miles Mallory, 2021 (1st), 2022 (2nd), 2023 (1st)
C Matt Meehan, 1999 (HM)
F Jared Mills, 2003 (4th)
F Justin Wansley, 2005 (3rd)

Redlands
G Amir Mazarei, 2007 (2nd)

Rhode Island College
G Tahrike Carter, 2013 (3rd) 

Rhodes
C Neal Power, 2001 (3rd)

Ripon
G Tommy Becker, 2005 (HM)
G Ty Sabin, 2015 (HM), 2016 (2nd), 2017 (1st)
F Aris Wurtz, 2012 (3rd)

Rochester
F Ryan Algier, 2021 (2nd)
G Sam Borst-Smith, 2017 (2nd)
G Mike Chmielowiec, 2009 (2nd)
G John DiBartolomeo, 2013 (1st, Player of the Year)
F Seth Hauben, 2005 (1st)
F Jeff Joss, 2002 (HM)

Rochester Tech
C Mark Carson, 2009 (3rd)

Rose-Hulman
G Bryan Egli, 1999 (3rd)
G Julian Strickland, 2014 (HM)

Rowan
C Mo Davis, 2000 (2nd)
G Ja'Zere Noel, 2023 (5th)
C Rob Scott, 1998 (3rd)

Rutgers-Camden
G Brian Turner, 2002 (HM)

Rutgers-Newark
F Jordan McDaniel, 2016 (3rd) 

Salem State
C Ifesinachi Anosike, 2005 (HM)
F Eric Downie, 2007 (4th)
C Khris Silveria, 1998 (HM)

Sewanee
C Ryan Harrigan, 1998 (2nd)

Simpson
C Adam Doll, 1998 (1st), 1999 (2nd)

Skidmore
G Aldin Medunjanin, 2017 (HM) 

Springfield
G Jake Ross, 2018 (2nd), 2019 (3rd), 2020 (1st)

St. John Fisher
F Dan Cook, 2023 (4th)
F Keegan Ryan, 2015 (HM), 2017 (3rd)

St. John's
F Aaron Burtzel, 2011 (HM) 

St. Joseph (Conn.)
G Jaecee Martin, 2022 (5th)

St. Mary's (Md.)
G Alex Franz, 2011 (4th)
G Nicholas LaGuerre 2015 (4th)

St. Mary's (Minn.)
G Raheem Anthony, 2023 (1st)

St. Norbert
G Brandon Gries, 2014 (HM)
C Nathan Hoffmann, 2002 (3rd)
F Andrew Schwoerer, 2015 (HM)

St. Thomas
G Mark Buri, 2002 (2nd)
C Tommy Hannon, 2013 (HM)
G Riley Miller, 2021 (3rd)
G Tyler Nicolai, 2011 (2nd)
C Isaac Rosefelt, 2006 (2nd), 2007 (2nd)
G Bryan Schnettler, 2007 (HM)
G Grant Shaeffer, 2017 (HM) 

Staten Island
F Will Fonseca, 2015 (3rd), 2016 (3rd)
F David Paul, 2002 (3rd)

Stockton
F Josh Blamon, 2015 (2nd)

Sul Ross State
G Sidney Hooper, 2006 (3rd)

SUNY Geneseo
F Gordon Lyons, 2015 (2nd)

SUNYIT
F David Golembiowski, 2011 (2nd) 
F Josh Gregory, 2022 (4th)

SUNY-Purchase
G Marvin Billups, 2011 (HM)
G Andre Nixon, 2014 (4th) 

SUNY Potsdam
F Isaiah Brown, 2020 (3rd)

Susquehanna
F Josh Miller, 2016 (4th)
G Steven Weidlich, 2017 (4th) 

Swarthmore
G Vinny DeAngelo, 2023 (4th)
F Zac O'Dell, 2019 (3rd)
F Nate Shafer, 2020 (4th)
G Cam Wiley, 2019 (3rd)

TCNJ
Travis Jocelyn, 2021 (3rd)

Texas-Dallas

F Kyle Schleigh, 2013 (3rd), 2014 (3rd)
G Demetrius Underwood, 2021 (2nd)

Texas Lutheran
C Tommy Stolhandske, 2005 (2nd)

Trine
G Nick Bowman, 2021 (1st)
G Ian Jackson, 2013 (HM) 

Trinity (Conn.)
F Ed Ogundeko, 2017 (HM)
C Tyler Rhoten, 2004 (3rd)
G Colin Tabb, 2002 (4th)

Tufts
F Luke Rogers, 2020 (3rd)

Union
G Aaron Galletta, 2002 (3rd)

Ursinus
G Mike McGarvey, 2005 (4th), 2006 (2nd)
G Nick Shattuck, 2008 (2nd)
G Dennis Stanton, 2004 (2nd)

UW-Eau Claire
F Sherm Carstensen, 2000 (3rd), 2001 (1st)
C Jon Wallenfelsz, 2000 (1st)

UW-La Crosse
G Ethan Anderson, 2022 (4th)
G Tony Mane, 2011 (3rd)
G Jared Staege, 2016 (3rd)
F Joe Werner, 2007 (4th)

UW-Oshkosh
G Ben Boots, 2019 (1st)
F Levi Borchert, 2021 (3rd), 2022 (2nd), 2023 (2nd)
F Tim Dworak, 2002 (3rd), 2003 (1st)
F Adam Fravert, 2020 (2nd)
C Jack Flynn, 2019 (4th), 2020 (2nd)
F D.J. Marsh, 2009 (3rd), 2010 (2nd)

UW-Platteville
G Merrill Brunson, 1999 (1st), 2000 (1st)
C Chas Cross, 2013 (4th)
G Robert Duax, 2018 (3rd)
G Ben Hoffmann, 1998 (3rd)
C Jeff Skemp, 2008 (3rd), 2009 (1st)
G Carter Voelker, 2020 (3rd)

UW-River Falls
F Alex Herink, 2017 (2nd)
F Rich Melzer, 2003 (2nd), 2004 (1st)

UW-Stevens Point
F Brant Bailey, 2000 (1st)
G Nick Bennett, 2005 (1st)
G Trevor Hass, 2014 (4th)
F Jason Kalsow, 2005 (1st)
F Alex Richard, 2015 (4th)
G Tyler Tillema, 2014 (1st) 

UW-Superior
F Vince Thomas, 2001 (2nd)

UW-Whitewater
F Chris Davis, 2012 (Player of the Year, 1st)
G KJ Evans, 2014 (HM)
G Matt Goodwin, 2008 (3rd)
G Myles McKay, 2009 (2nd)
C Dustin Mitchell, 2010 (4th)
F James Stewart, 1998 (HM)
G Quardell Young, 2015 (1st)

Villa Julie/Stevenson
F Anthony Fitzgerald, 2006 (HM)

Virginia Wesleyan
F Brandon Adair, 2006 (1st), 2007 (2nd)
G DJ Woodmore, 2012 (HM), 2014 (2nd)

Wabash
G Jack Davidson, 2022 (1st)
G Josh Estelle, 1998 (2nd), 1999 (3rd), 2000 (3rd)
F Wes Smith, 2011 (3rd)

Washington U.
F Chris Jeffries, 2003 (2nd)
F Chris Klimek, 2014 (HM)
G Jack Nolan, 2020 (3rd), 2022 (3rd)
G Dylan Richter, 2012 (HM)
F Troy Ruths, 2007 (HM), 2008 (Player of the Year, 1st)
F Andrew Sanders, 2018 (1st)
G Aaron Thompson, 2009 (1st), 2010 (3rd)
G Sean Wallis, 2009 (2nd), 2010 (1st)

Wesley
G Brian Cameron, 2020 (2nd)
G Rashawn Johnson, 2009 (4th)
C David Langan, 2014 (3rd)
F Paul Reynolds, 2013 (4th) 

Wesleyan
G Leo Jones, 2002 (3rd)
G Sam Peek, 2022 (5th)

Western Connecticut
G DaQuan Brooks, 2012 (3rd)

Wheaton (Ill.)
G Nyameye Adom, 2021 (2nd), 2022 (3rd)
G Tyson Cruickshank, 2023 (1st)
G Aston Francis, 2018 (2nd), 2019 (1st, Player of the Year)
C Joel Kolmodin, 2003 (1st), 2004 (1st)
F Tim McCrary, 2010 (2nd), 2011 (4th), 2012 (1st)
G Ben Panner, 2010 (HM)
G Tyler Peters, 2014 (3rd)
G Kent Raymond, 2008 (1st), 2009 (1st)

Whitman
F Austin Butler, 2019 (1st)
G Tim Howell, 2017 (3rd), 2018 (HM)
F David Michaels, 2012 (4th)

Whitworth
G Ben College, 2019 (HM), 2020 (4th)
F Brian Depew, 2004 (3rd)
C Nate Montgomery, 2010 (4th)
G Kyle Roach, 2018 (1st)
G Michael Taylor, 2011 (Player of the Year, 1st) 
F George Valle, 2016 (HM) 

Wilkes
G Dave Jannuzzi, 2001 (2nd)

William Paterson
F Lance Brown, 2012 (HM)
G Horace Jenkins, 1999 (HM), 2000 (2nd), 2001 (1st)

Williams
G Bobby Casey, 2019 (HM)
F Ben Coffin, 2004 (2nd)
G Michael Crotty, 2003 (3rd), 2004 (1st)
C Michael Mayer, 2012 (3rd), 2014 (1st)
F Michael Nogelo, 1998 (1st)
F Duncan Robinson, 2014 (4th)
F Blake Schultz, 2010 (1st)
G James Wang, 2010 (4th), 2011 (3rd)
C Troy Whittington, 2011 (1st)

Wilmington
F Malcolm Heard II, 2014 (4th) 

Wittenberg
F Dane Borchers, 2007 (3rd)
C Chad Roy, 2018 (4th)
F Dan Russ, 2006 (2nd)
G Chris Sullivan, 2011 (HM) 

Wooster
G Xavier Brown, 2014 (3rd)
G James Cooper, 2006 (HM), 2007 (2nd), 2008 (1st)
G Ian Franks, 2010 (4th), 2011 (1st)
F Justin Hallowell, 2012 (3rd)
F Bryan Nelson, 2003 (4th)
F Tom Port, 2006 (4th), 2007 (2nd)

WPI
G Ryan Cain, 2007 (3rd)

Yeshiva
F Gabriel Leifer, 2020 (4th), 2021 (2nd)
F Ryan Turell, 2020 (1st), 2021 (1st), 2022 (1st)

York (N.Y.)
C Marcel Esonwune, 2010 (2nd), 2011 (4th)

York (Pa.)
F Chad McGowan, 2007 (HM), 2008 (HM)
G Andy O'Brien, 2003 (HM)