| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Horace Jenkins | Sr. | William Paterson | Elizabeth, N.J. |
| G | Ryan Knuppel | Sr. | Elmhurst | Manito, Ill. |
| F | Sherm Carstensen | Sr. | UW-Eau Claire | Eau Claire, Wis. |
| F | Kris Oberdick | Sr. | Ohio Northern | Toledo, Ohio |
| C | Derek Reich | So. | Chicago | Niles, Ill. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Dave Jannuzzi | Sr. | Wilkes | Wilkes-Barre, Pa. |
| G | Pat Maloney | Sr. | Catholic | Brant Beach, N.J. |
| F | Jason Wiertel | Jr. | Carthage | Buffalo Grove, Ill. |
| F | Vince Thomas | Sr. | UW-Superior | Wheaton, Ill. |
| C | Jeff Gibbs | Jr. | Otterbein | Columbus, Ohio |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Johnny Garrett | Sr. | Merchant Marine | Missouri City, Texas |
| G | Alex Denson | Sr. | McMurry | Brownsville, Texas |
| F | Antoine Sinclair | Sr. | Christopher Newport | Hampton, Va. |
| F | Robert Moore | Jr. | Mary Hardin-Baylor | Dallas, Texas |
| C | Neal Power | Sr. | Rhodes | Mayfield, Ky. |
| Fourth Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Corey Dickerson | Sr. | King's | Philadelphia, Pa. |
| G | Tom Williams | Sr. | Cortland State | East Northport, N.Y. |
| F | Kyle Williford | Jr. | Bridgewater (Va.) | Raleigh, N.C. |
| F | Jeremy Veenstra | So. | Calvin | Kalamazoo, Mich. |
| C | Mark Lesko | Jr. | Muhlenberg | Scranton, Pa. |
| Honorable Mention | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Yr. | School | Hometown |
| G | Willie Chandler | So. | Misericordia | Scranton, Pa. |
| G | Kareem Tatum | Sr. | Connecticut College | Worcester, Mass. |
| F | Luke Kasten | So. | Illinois Wesleyan | Coffeen, Ill. |
| F | Chris Coates | Sr. | Keene State | Hampton, N.H. |
| C | Justin Muth | Sr. | Cal Lutheran | Montara, Calif. |