The D3hoops.com Top 25 began in November 1999. Here's easy access to all of the polls from previous seasons:
| 2023-24 | |||
| Poll | No. 1 team (votes) | Teams receiving No. 1 votes | Teams rec. votes |
| Preseason | Christopher Newport (24) | 2 (UW-Whitewater) | 54 |
| Week 1 | UW-Whitewater (13) | 5 (Hampden-Sydney 8, John Carroll 2, Mount Union, Calvin) | 54 |
| Week 2 | John Carroll (13) | 4 (Guilford 6, Calvin 5, Oswego State) | 45 |
| Week 3 | John Carroll (13) | 5 (Calvin 5, Guilford 4, Tufts 2, Oswego State) | 40 |
| Week 4 | Hampden-Sydney (13) | 6 (Case Western 8, Guilford, Trinity (Texas), Tufts, UW-Whitewater) | 41 |
| Week 5 | Hampden-Sydney (20) | 5 (Guiflord 2, Trinity (Conn.), Trinity (Texas), UW-Whitewater) | 50 |
| Week 6 | Hampden-Sydney (23) | 2 (Trinity (Conn.) 2) | 47 |
| Week 7 | Hampden-Sydney (24) | 2 (Trinity (Conn.)) | 47 |
| Week 8 | Hampden-Sydney (23) | 3 (Trine, Trinity (Conn.)) | 50 |
| Week 9 | John Carroll (12) | 4 (Trine 8, Hampden-Sydney 3, Randolph-Macon 2) | 44 |
| Week 10 | John Carroll (16) | 4 (Hampden-Sydney 6, Randolph-Macon 2, Trinity (Texas)) | 44 |
| Week 11 | Hampden-Sydney (21) | 2 (Randolph-Macon 4) | 44 |
| Week 12 | Hampden-Sydney (25) | 1 | 49 |
| Final | Trine (25) | Trine was No. 13 | 39 |
| 2022-23 | |||
| Poll | No. 1 team (votes) | Teams receiving No. 1 votes | Teams rec. votes |
| Preseason | Randolph-Macon (17) | 4 (Mary Hardin-Baylor 4, Christopher Newport 2, UW-Oshkosh 2) | 61 |
| Week 1 | Christopher Newport (15) | 4 (Mount Union 5, UW-La Crosse 2, Randolph-Macon, St. Joseph (Conn.)) | 49 |
| Week 2 | Christopher Newport (20) | 3 (UW-La Crosse 4, St. Joseph (Conn.)) | 52 |
| Week 3 | Christopher Newport (23) | 2 (St. Joseph (Conn.) 2) | 52 |
| Week 4 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (21) | 3 (Randolph-Macon 3, Williams) | 49 |
| Week 5 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (21) | 3 (Randolph-Macon 3, Keene State) | 48 |
| Week 6 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (22) | 2 (Randolph-Macon 3) | 42 |
| Week 7 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (19) | 2 (Randolph-Macon 6) | 40 |
| Week 8 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (19) | 2 (Randolph-Macon 6) | 40 |
| Week 9 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (15) | 2 (Randolph-Macon 10) | 37 |
| Week 10 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (15) | 2 (Randolph-Macon 10) | 41 |
| Week 11 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (15) | 2 (Randolph-Macon 10) | 38 |
| Week 12 | St. Joseph (Conn.) (14) | 2 (Randolph-Macon 11) | 39 |
| Week 13 | Randolph-Macon (25) | 1 | 45 |
| Final | Christopher Newport (25) | CNU was No. 2 | 40 |
| 2021-22 | |||
| Poll | No. 1 team (votes) | Teams receiving No. 1 votes | Teams rec. votes |
| Preseason | Randolph-Macon (19) | 5 (Yeshiva 3, Illinois Wesleyan, Swarthmore, Whitworth) | 64 |
| Week 1 | Yeshiva (13) | 4 (Randoph-Macon 8, Illinois Wesleyan3, UW-Platteville) | 46 |
| Week 2 | Yeshiva (13) | 4 (Randolph-Macon 8, Illinois Wesleyan 3, UW-Platteville) | 49 |
| Week 3 | Yeshiva (13) | 3 (Randolph-Macon 10, UW-Platteville 2) | 46 |
| Week 4 | Randolph-Macon (15) | 3 (UW-Platteville 9, Illinois Wesleyan) | 42 |
| Week 5 | Randolph-Macon (17) | 2 (Illinois Wesleyan 8) | 44 |
| Week 6 | Randolph-Macon (19) | 2 (UW-Platteville 6) | 40 |
| Week 7 | Randolph-Macon (24) | 2 (Christopher Newport) | 40 |
| Week 8 | Randolph-Macon (25) | 1 | 39 |
| Week 9 | Randolph-Macon (25) | 1 | 37 |
| Week 10 | Randolph-Macon (25) | 1 | 41 |
| Week 11 | Randolph-Macon (25) | 1 | 40 |
| Week 12 | Randolph-Macon (25) | 1 | 38 |
| Final | Randolph-Macon (25) | 1 | 39 |
2020-21 |
|||
| Poll | No. 1 team (votes) | Teams receiving No. 1 votes | Teams rec. votes |
| Week 1 | Randolph-Macon (15/18) | 4 (Mount Union, St. John's, Whitworth) | 23 (Top 10) |
| Week 2 | Randolph-Macon (15/18) | 4 (Mount Union, St. John's, Whitworth) | 32 (Top 15) |
| Week 3 | Randolph-Macon (16/18) | 3 (St. John's, Whitworth) | 25 (Top 15) |
| Week 4 | Randolph-Macon (14/18) | 4 (Trine 2, Illinois Wesleyan, St. John's) | 27 (Top 15) |
| Week 5 | Randolph-Macon (15/18) | 2 (Trine) | 27 (Top 15) |
| Week 6 | Randolph-Macon (14/18) | 3 (Trine 3, St. Thomas) | 23 (Top 15) |
| Week 7 | Randolph-Macon (15/18) | 2 (St. Thomas) | 26 (Top 15) |
| Week 8 | Randolph-Macon (15/18) | 2 (St. Thomas) | 26 (Top 15) |
| 2020-21 ballots feature a varying number of teams and voters because of the pandemic. Voters could only vote for teams that had played a countable game. | |||
2019-20 |
|||
| Preseason | Swarthmore (16) | 3 (UW-Oshkosh 8, North Central, Ill.) | 50 |
| Week 1 | Swarthmore (23) | 2 (Emory) | 45 |
| Week 2 | Swarthmore (22) | 2 (Emory) | 45 |
| Week 3 | Swarthmore (21) | 2 (Emory) | 47 |
| Week 4 | Swarthmore (21) | 2 (Emory) | 46 |
| Week 5 | Swarthmore (25) | 1 | 48 |
| Week 6 | Swarthmore (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 7 | Swarthmore (25) | 1 | 44 |
| Week 8 | Swarthmore (25) | 1 | 40 |
| Week 9 | Swarthmore (21) | 3 (St. John's 3, Randolph-Macon) | 43 |
| Week 10 | Swarthmore (20) | 3 (St. John's 4, Randolph-Macon) | 44 |
| Week 11 | Swarthmore (22) | 3 (Randolph-Macon 2, St. John's) | 38 |
| Week 12 | Swarthmore (24) | 2 (UW-Platteville) | 41 |
| Week 13 | Swarthmore (15) | 4 (St. John's 6, Randolph-Macon 3, Mount Union) | 42 |
| Final | Swarthmore (18) | 5 (Mount Union 3, Randolph-Macon 2, St. John's, St. Thomas) |
40 |
2018-19 |
|||
| Pre | Neb. Wesleyan (24) | 2 (Augustana) | 55 |
| Week 1 | Neb. Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 48 |
| Week 2 | Neb. Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 45 |
| Week 3 | Neb. Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 40 |
| Week 4 | Neb. Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 40 |
| Week 5 | Neb. Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 6 | Neb. Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 41 |
| Week 7 | Neb. Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 8 | Augustana (13) | 4 (Neb. Wesleyan 9, Whitman 2, UW-Oshkosh) | 44 |
| Week 9 | Neb. Wesleyan (18) | 3 (Whitman 6, UW-Oshkosh) | 39 |
| Week 10 | Neb. Wesleyan (20) | 3 (Whitman 4, UW-Oshkosh) | 42 |
| Week 11 | Neb. Wesleyan (21) | 2 (Whitman 4) | 44 |
| Week 12 | Neb. Wesleyan (21) | 2 (Whitman 4) | 44 |
| Final | UW-Oshkosh (25) | UW-Oshkosh was No. 4 | 39 |
2017-18 |
|||
| Pre | Whitman (23) | 2 (Babson) | 50 |
| Week 1 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 52 |
| Week 2 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 50 |
| Week 3 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 46 |
| Week 4 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 44 |
| Week 5 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 6 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 45 |
| Week 7 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 46 |
| Week 8 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 9 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 10 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 42 |
| Week 11 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 12 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 39 |
| Week 13 | Whitman (18) | 4 (Whitworth 4, Wittenberg 2, Washington U.) | 42 |
| Final | Neb. Wesleyan (25) | Neb. Wesleyan was unranked | 37 |
2016-17 |
|||
| Pre | Amherst (10) | 5 (Christopher Newport 6, Babson 6, Benedictine 2, St. Thomas) |
55 |
| Week 1 | Amherst (19) | 3 (Babson 5, Marietta) | 51 |
| Week 2 | Amherst (19) | 3 (Babson 5, Marietta) | 49 |
| Week 3 | Amherst (22) | 2 (Babson 3) | 51 |
| Week 4 | Babson (15) | 3 (Whitman 9, Marietta) | 46 |
| Week 5 | Babson (15) | 3 (Whitman 9, Marietta) | 42 |
| Week 6 | Babson (15) | 2 (Whitman 10) | 42 |
| Week 7 | Babson (15) | 2 (Whitman 10) | 38 |
| Week 8 | Babson (15) | 2 (Whitman 10) | 37 |
| Week 9 | Babson (14) | 2 (Whitman 11) | 39 |
| Week 10 | Babson (14) | 2 (Whitman 11) | 37 |
| Week 11 | Babson (14) | 2 (Whitman 11) | 39 |
| Week 12 | Babson (15) | 2 (Whitman 10) | 43 |
| Week 13 | Whitman (25) | 1 | 48 |
| Final | Babson (25) | Babson was No. 3 | 43 |
2015-16 |
|||
| Pre | Augustana (23) | 2 (Amherst 2) | 51 |
| Week 1 | Augustana (25) | 1 | 59 |
| Week 2 | Augustana (25) | 1 | 56 |
| Week 3 | Augustana (25) | 1 | 58 |
| Week 4 | Augustana (25) | 1 | 57 |
| Week 5 | Whitworth (15) | 5 (Augustana 5, Elmhurst 2, Hope 2, Benedictine) |
52 |
| Week 6 | Whitworth (14) | 5 (Augustana 5, Elmhurst 4, Benedictine, John Carroll) |
48 |
| Week 7 | Whitworth (18) | 4 (Augustana 5, Benedictine, John Carroll) | 45 |
| Week 8 | Whitworth (16) | 3 (Augustana 8, John Carroll) | 46 |
| Week 9 | Augustana (17) | 4 (Benedictine 5, John Carroll 2, Whitworth) | 42 |
| Week 10 | Augustana (17) | 2 (Benedictine 8) | 46 |
| Week 11 | Augustana (15) | 2 (Benedictine 10) | 45 |
| Week 12 | Augustana (17) | 2 (Benedictine 8) | 45 |
| Final | St. Thomas (25) | St. Thomas was No. 8 | 46 |
2014-15 |
|||
| Pre | UW-Whitewater (18) | 3 (Augustana 6, Illinois Wesleyan) | 60 |
| Week 1 | Augustana (16) | 4 (Amherst 4, UW-Whitewater 4, Wooster) | 54 |
| Week 2 | Augustana (17) | 3 (Amherst 4, UW-Whitewater 4) | 51 |
| Week 3 | UW-Whitewater (9) | 3 (Amherst 11, Washington U. 5) | 53 |
| Week 4 | Washington U. (23) | 2 (Augustana) | 48 |
| Week 5 | Washington U. (22) | 2 (Augustana) | 46 |
| Week 6 | Augustana (24) | 2 (St. Thomas) | 46 |
| Week 7 | Augustana (24) | 2 (St. Thomas) | 40 |
| Week 8 | UW-Whitewater (16) | 3 (St. Thomas 7, Marietta 2) | 39 |
| Week 9 | UW-Whitewater (16) | 3 (St. Thomas 5, Marietta 4) | 41 |
| Week 10 | UW-Whitewater (14) | 3 (Marietta 6, St. Thomas 5) | 42 |
| Week 11 | Randolph-Macon (12) | 5 (UW-Whitewater 9, Albertus Magnus 2, St. Thomas, UW-Stevens Pt.) |
43 |
| Week 12 | Randolph-Macon (14) | 3 (UW-Whitewater 10, Albertus Magnus) | 39 |
| Week 13 | Randolph-Macon (13) | 3 (UW-Whitewater 11, Albertus Magnus) | 44 |
| Final | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | UW-Stevens Pt. was No. 8 | 43 |
2013-14 |
|||
| Pre | Amherst (13) | 5 (Illinois Wesleyan 9, UW-Stevens Pt., Wheaton (Ill.), Williams) |
50 |
| Week 1 | Amherst (16) | 4 (UW-Stevens Pt. 6, Washington U. 2, UW-Whitewater) | 62 |
| Week 2 | Amherst (18) | 3 (UW-Stevens Pt. 6, UW-Whitewater) | 57 |
| Week 3 | UW-Stevens Pt. (16) | 3 (Wooster 8, Cabrini) | 52 |
| Week 4 | UW-Stevens Pt. (19) | 3 (Wooster 5, Cabrini) | 50 |
| Week 5 | UW-Stevens Pt. (23) | 3 (Cabrini, Wooster) | 47 |
| Week 6 | UW-Stevens Pt. (23) | 3 (Cabrini, Wooster) | 45 |
| Week 7 | UW-Stevens Pt. (23) | 3 (Cabrini, Wooster) | 51 |
| Week 8 | UW-Stevens Pt. (24) | 2 (Cabrini) | 47 |
| Week 9 | UW-Stevens Pt. (24) | 2 (Cabrini) | 45 |
| Week 10 | UW-Stevens Pt. (14) | 2 (Cabrini 11) | 44 |
| Week 11 | UW-Stevens Pt. (24) | 2 (UW-Whitewater) | 49 |
| Week 12 | UW-Stevens Pt. (24) | 2 (UW-Whitewater) | 44 |
| Week 13 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 40 |
| Final | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | UW-Stevens Pt. was No. 1 | 39 |
2012-13 |
|||
| Pre | MIT (12) | 3 (UW-Whitewater 10, Va. Wesleyan 3) | 56 |
| Week 1 | MIT (10) | 4 (UW-Whitewater 8, Va. Wesleyan 6, St. Thomas) | 50 |
| Week 2 | Va. Wesleyan (13) | 4 (UW-Whitewater 10, Middlebury, St. Thomas) | 48 |
| Week 3 | Va. Wesleyan (12) | 4 (UW-Whitewater 11, Middlebury, St. Thomas) | 43 |
| Week 4 | Va. Wesleyan (21) | 4 (Middlebury 2, North Central (Ill.), St. Thomas) | 43 |
| Week 5 | North Central, Ill. (12) | 3 (Middlebury 9, St. Thomas 4) | 48 |
| Week 6 | North Central, Ill. (14) | 3 (Middlebury 6, St. Thomas 5) | 45 |
| Week 7 | St. Thomas (18) | 3 (Middlebury 4, Rochester 3) | 44 |
| Week 8 | St. Thomas (19) | 3 (Middlebury 4, Rochester 2) | 39 |
| Week 9 | Rochester (23) | 2 (St. Thomas 2) | 47 |
| Week 10 | St. Thomas (13) | 3 (WPI 8, Whitworth 4) | 39 |
| Week 11 | St. Thomas (25) | 1 | 36 |
| Week 12 | St. Thomas (24) | 2 (Amherst) | 46 |
| Week 13 | St. Thomas (24) | 2 (Amherst 2) | 39 |
| Final | Amherst (25) | Amherst was No. 2 | 42 |
2011-12 |
|||
| Pre | Va. Wesleyan (8) | 5 (Williams 7, Middlebury 5, Augustana 2, St. Thomas 2) |
60 |
| Week 1 | Augustana (15) | 5 (Middlebury 6, Amherst 2, Marietta, Va. Wesleyan) |
54 |
| Week 2 | Middlebury (13) | 4 (Amherst 10, Va. Wesleyan, Whitworth) | 53 |
| Week 3 | Middlebury (24) | 2 (Va. Wesleyan) | 45 |
| Week 4 | Middlebury (24) | 2 (Va. Wesleyan) | 46 |
| Week 5 | Middlebury (23) | 3 (MIT, Va. Wesleyan) | 48 |
| Week 6 | Middlebury (23) | 3 (MIT, Va. Wesleyan) | 47 |
| Week 7 | Middlebury (22) | 3 (Va. Wesleyan 2, MIT) | 48 |
| Week 8 | Middlebury (24) | 2 (UW-Whitewater) | 44 |
| Week 9 | Middlebury (24) | 2 (Va. Wesleyan) | 49 |
| Week 10 | Hope (15) | 4 (Middlebury 5, Va. Wesleyan 4, UW-Whitewater) | 47 |
| Week 11 | Hope (23) | 3 (Amherst, MIT) | 44 |
| Week 12 | Hope (23) | 3 (Amherst, MIT) | 43 |
| Week 13 | Hope (21) | 3 (Amherst 3, MIT) | 43 |
| Final | UW-Whitewater (25) | UW-Whitewater was No. 8 | 48 |
2010-11 |
|||
| Pre | UW-Stevens Pt. (21) | 3 (Illinois Wesleyan 2, Randolph-Macon 2) | 61 |
| Week 1 | UW-Stevens Pt. (22) | 2 (Illinois Wesleyan 3) | 52 |
| Week 2 | Wooster (12) | 6 (Williams 5, UW-SP 3, Va. Wesleyan 3, Wabash, Whitworth) |
48 |
| Week 3 | Wooster (11) | 6 (Williams 5, UW-SP 4, Va. Wesleyan 3, Wabash, Whitworth) |
43 |
| Week 4 | Wooster (11) | 6 (Williams 5, UW-SP 4, Va. Wesleyan 3, Wabash, Whitworth) |
39 |
| Week 5 | Wooster (14) | 5 (Williams 5, Whitworth 3, Va. Wesleyan 2, Wabash) |
38 |
| Week 6 | Wooster (19) | 3 (Va. Wesleyan 3, Whitworth 3) | 41 |
| Week 7 | Wooster (19) | 4 (Whitworth 3, Va. Wesleyan 2, St. Thomas) | 44 |
| Week 8 | Wooster (21) | 3 (Whitworth 3, Augustana) | 46 |
| Week 9 | Wooster (20) | 3 (Whitworth 3, Augustana 2) | 40 |
| Week 10 | Whitworth (19) | 4 (Amherst 3, Williams 2, Wooster) | 38 |
| Week 11 | Whitworth (21) | 2 (Williams 4) | 40 |
| Week 12 | Williams (18) | 3 (Whitworth 6, UW-Stevens Pt.) | 41 |
| Week 13 | Whitworth (14) | 4 (Middlebury 8, UW-Stevens Pt. 2, Wooster) | 48 |
| Final | St. Thomas (25) | St. Thomas was No. 8 | 48 |
2009-10 |
|||
| Pre | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 59 |
| Week 1 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 51 |
| Week 2 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 46 |
| Week 3 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 44 |
| Week 4 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 5 | Randolph-Macon (12) | 3 (UW-Stevens Pt. 9, Washington U. 4) | 44 |
| Week 6 | Randolph-Macon (12) | 3 (UW-Stevens Pt. 10, Washington U. 3) | 42 |
| Week 7 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 41 |
| Week 8 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 37 |
| Week 9 | Guilford (24) | 2 (Washington U.) | 33 |
| Week 10 | Guilford (23) | 3 (Washington U., Williams) | 42 |
| Week 11 | Washington U. (13) | 2 (Williams 12) | 36 |
| Week 12 | Washington U. (13) | 2 (Williams 12) | 39 |
| Week 13 | Washington U. (14) | 2 (Williams 11) | 42 |
| Final | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | UW-Stevens Pt. was No. 5 | 38 |
2008-09 |
|||
| Pre | Washington U. (23) | 3 (UW-Platteville, UW-Whitewater) | 53 |
| Week 1 | Washington U. (23) | 3 (UW-Platteville, UW-Whitewater) | 51 |
| Week 2 | Washington U. (24) | 2 (UW-Platteville) | 51 |
| Week 3 | Washington U. (23) | 2 (UW-Platteville 2) | 44 |
| Week 4 | UW-Platteville (13) | 4 (Wheaton, Ill. 7, St. Thomas 3, Washington U. 2) | 42 |
| Week 5 | Wheaton, Ill. (16) | 4 (St. Thomas 4, UW-Platteville 3, Washington U. 2) | 42 |
| Week 6 | Wheaton, Ill. (18) | 3 (St. Thomas 5, Washington U. 2) | 43 |
| Week 7 | Wheaton, Ill. (18) | 3 (St. Thomas 5, Washington U. 2) | 39 |
| Week 8 | St. Thomas (18) | 2 (Washington U. 7) | 43 |
| Week 9 | St. Thomas (18) | 2 (Washington U. 7) | 40 |
| Week 10 | St. Thomas (17) | 2 (Washington U. 8) | 39 |
| Week 11 | St. Thomas (17) | 2 (Washington U. 8) | 40 |
| Week 12 | St. Thomas (24) | 2 (Washington U.) | 38 |
| Week 13 | St. Thomas (22) | 3 (Wheaton, Ill. 2, Washington U.) | 40 |
| Final | Washington U. (25) | Washington U. was No. 2 | 43 |
2007-08 |
|||
| Pre | Washington U. (15) | 4 (Amherst 8, Brockport State 1, UW-Stevens Pt. 1) | 57 |
| Week 1 | Amherst (17) | 3 (UW-Stevens Pt. 7, Augustana 1) | 46 |
| Week 2 | Amherst (23) | 3 (Rochester, UW-Stevens Pt.) | 47 |
| Week 3 | Rochester (13) | 7 (UW-Stevens Pt. 5, Amherst 2, Brandeis 2, Hope, UW-Oshkosh, Williams) |
47 |
| Week 4 | Rochester (14) | 6 (UW-Stevens Pt. 5, Amherst 2, Brandeis 2, Hope, Williams) |
48 |
| Week 5 | Rochester (16) | 4 (UW-Stevens Pt. 5, Brandeis 3, Williams) | 48 |
| Week 6 | Rochester (18) | 3 (Brandeis 6, Williams) | 45 |
| Week 7 | Rochester (19) | 2 (Brandeis 6) | 43 |
| Week 8 | Rochester (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 9 | Washington U. (11) | 4 (Amherst 8, Mass-Dartmouth, Rochester 3) | 40 |
| Week 10 | Amherst (18) | 2 (Mass-Dartmouth 7) | 43 |
| Week 11 | Amherst (24) | 2 (Mass-Dartmouth) | 39 |
| Week 12 | Amherst (24) | 2 (Centre) | 39 |
| Week 13 | Amherst (24) | 2 (Centre) | 39 |
| Final | Washington U. (25) | Washington U. was No. 7 | 39 |
2006-07 |
|||
| Pre | Va. Wesleyan (23) | 3 (Amherst, Wooster) | 65 |
| Week 1 | Va. Wesleyan (23) | 3 (Amherst, Wooster) | 68 |
| Week 2 | Wooster (21) | 2 (Amherst 4) | 53 |
| Week 3 | Wooster (22) | 2 (Amherst 3) | 48 |
| Week 4 | Wooster (22) | 2 (Amherst 3) | 48 |
| Week 5 | UW-Stevens Pt. (9) | 3 (Amherst 9, Ohio Northern 7) | 47 |
| Week 6 | UW-Stevens Pt. (15) | 2 (Amherst 10) | 47 |
| Week 7 | UW-Stevens Pt. (17) | 2 (Amherst 8) | 45 |
| Week 8 | UW-Stevens Pt. (17) | 2 (Amherst 8) | 38 |
| Week 9 | Amherst (18) | 4 (UW-Stevens Pt. 4, Wooster 2, Washington U.) | 44 |
| Week 10 | Amherst (19) | 2 (UW-Stevens Pt. 6) | 42 |
| Week 11 | UW-Stevens Pt. (21) | 3 (Amherst 3, Va. Wesleyan) | 45 |
| Week 12 | UW-Stevens Pt. (21) | 3 (Amherst 3, Va. Wesleyan) | 45 |
| Week 13 | UW-Stevens Pt. (24) | 2 (Amherst) | 46 |
| Final | Amherst (25) | Amherst was No. 6 | 49 |
2005-06 |
|||
| Pre | Illinois Wesleyan (19) | 5 (UW-Oshkosh 3, Hanover, St. John Fisher, Wooster) |
55 |
| Week 1 | Illinois Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 49 |
| Week 2 | Illinois Wesleyan (25) | 1 | 44 |
| Week 3 | Illinois Wesleyan (23) | 3 (Amherst, Wooster) | 45 |
| Week 4 | Illinois Wesleyan (23) | 3 (Amherst, Wooster) | 43 |
| Week 5 | Illinois Wesleyan (24) | 2 (Amherst) | 44 |
| Week 6 | Wittenberg (8) | 5 (Hope 9, Illinois Wesleyan 4, Albion 2, Wooster 2) | 43 |
| Week 7 | Wittenberg (15) | 3 (Albion 7, Wooster 3) | 43 |
| Week 8 | Wittenberg (15) | 3 (Wooster 8, Lawrence 2) | 42 |
| Week 9 | Wittenberg (15) | 4 (Wooster 7, Lawrence 2, Augustana) | 39 |
| Week 10 | Wooster (22) | 4 (Augustana, Baldwin Wallace, Lawrence) | 38 |
| Week 11 | Wooster (23) | 3 (Baldwin Wallace, Lawrence) | 40 |
| Week 12 | Lawrence (22) | 3 (Wooster 2, Hope) | 43 |
| Week 13 | Lawrence (21) | 2 (Hope 4) | 40 |
| Final | Va. Wesleyan (25) | Va. Wesleyan was No. 7 | 39 |
2004-05 |
|||
| Pre | UW-Stevens Pt. (24) | 2 (Rochester) | 69 |
| Week 1 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 52 |
| Week 2 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 55 |
| Week 3 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 48 |
| Week 4 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 44 |
| Week 5 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 6 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 42 |
| Week 7 | Wooster (14) | 3 (UW-Stevens Pt. 9, John Carroll 2) | 43 |
| Week 8 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 46 |
| Week 9 | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | 1 | 41 |
| Week 10 | Illinois Wesleyan (14) | 4 (UW-Stevens Pt. 5, Amherst 3, Wooster 3) | 45 |
| Week 11 | Illinois Wesleyan (13) | 4 (UW-Stevens Pt. 6, Amherst 3, Wooster 3) | 40 |
| Week 12 | UW-Stevens Pt. (16) | 3 (Wooster 6, Amherst 3) | 41 |
| Week 13 | Wooster (19) | 4 (Amherst 3, St. John Fisher 2, Illinois Wesleyan) | 40 |
| Week 14 | UW-Stevens Pt. (11) | 4 (Amherst 9, St. John Fisher 3, Illinois Wesleyan 2) | 39 |
| Final | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | UW-Stevens Pt. was No. 1 | 37 |
2003-04 |
|||
| Pre | Williams (19) | 6 (UW-SP 2, Augustana, Gustavus Adolphus, Hampden-Sydney, Wooster) |
54 |
| Week 1 | Williams (20) | 5 (UW-Stevens Pt. 2, Augustana, Hampden-Sydney, Wooster) |
51 |
| Week 2 | Williams (22) | 3 (UW-Stevens Pt. 2, Hampden-Sydney) | 49 |
| Week 3 | Williams (24) | 2 (UW-Stevens Pt.) | 51 |
| Week 4 | Williams (24) | 2 (UW-Stevens Pt.) | 48 |
| Week 5 | Williams (24) | 2 (UW-Stevens Pt.) | 44 |
| Week 6 | Williams (24) | 2 (UW-Stevens Pt.) | 46 |
| Week 7 | Hampden-Sydney (11) | 4 (Rochester 7, Amherst 6, Williams) | 40 |
| Week 8 | Amherst (13) | 3 (Rochster 10, Williams 2) | 39 |
| Week 9 | Rochester (17) | 2 (Williams 8) | 43 |
| Week 10 | Rochester (17) | 2 (Williams 8) | 43 |
| Week 11 | Williams (22) | 3 (Hanover 2, Randolph-Macon) | 43 |
| Week 12 | Williams (23) | 2 (Hanover 2) | 42 |
| Week 13 | Williams (23) | 2 (Hanover 2) | 40 |
| Week 14 | Williams (23) | 2 (Hanover 2) | 41 |
| Final | UW-Stevens Pt. (25) | UW-Stevens Pt. was No. 10 | 39 |
2002-03 |
|||
| Pre | Washington U. (15) | 6 (Capital 3, Carthage 3, Otterbein 2, Rochester, Williams) |
56 |
| Week 1 | Washington U. (19) | 4 (Capital 3, Rochester 2, Williams) | 48 |
| Week 2 | Washington U. (23) | 2 (Rochester 2) | 47 |
| Week 3 | Washington U. (23) | 2 (Rochester 2) | 51 |
| Week 4 | Washington U. (23) | 2 (Rochester 2) | 45 |
| Week 5 | Washington U. (23) | 2 (Rochester 2) | 41 |
| Week 6 | Washington U. (22) | 3 (Rochester 2, UW-Stevens Pt.) | 44 |
| Week 7 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 44 |
| Week 8 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 43 |
| Week 9 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 44 |
| Week 10 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 42 |
| Week 11 | Washington U. (25) | 1 | 41 |
| Week 12 | Randolph-Macon (17) | 4 (Washington U. 3, Williams 3, UW-Stevens Pt. 2) | 41 |
| Week 13 | Randolph-Macon (17) | 3 (Washington U. 5, Williams 3) | 44 |
| Final | Williams (25) | Williams was No. 3 | 42 |
2001-02 |
|||
| Pre | Carthage (13) | 4 (Catholic 7, Illinois Wesleyan 4, Christopher Newport) | 66 |
| Week 1 | Carthage (22) | 2 (Christopher Newport 3) | 49 |
| Week 2 | Carthage (22) | 2 (Christopher Newport 3) | 51 |
| Week 3 | Carthage (23) | 2 (Christopher Newport 2) | 52 |
| Week 4 | Carthage (23) | 2 (Christhoper Newport 2) | 47 |
| Week 5 | Carthage (24) | 2 (Christopher Newport) | 44 |
| Week 6 | Carthage (25) | 1 | 46 |
| Week 7 | Randolph-Macon (10) | 4 (Catholic 7, Carthage 6, Brockport State 2) | 42 |
| Week 8 | Randolph-Macon (10) | 4 (Carthage 8, Catholic 6, Brockport State) | 50 |
| Week 9 | Carthage (14) | 3 (Catholic 9, Washington U. 2) | 47 |
| Week 10 | Carthage (15) | 3 (Catholic 9, Washington U.) | 39 |
| Week 11 | Carthage (21) | 2 (Washington U. 4) | 40 |
| Week 12 | Carthage (21) | 2 (Washington U. 4) | 38 |
| Week 13 | Carthage (20) | 3 (Washington U. 4, UW-Oshkosh) | 44 |
| Final | Otterbein (25) | Otterbein was No. 6 | 44 |
2000-01 |
|||
| Pre | Calvin (13) | 4 (William Paterson 9, Carthage 2, Buena Vista) | 67 |
| Week 1 | Calvin (15) | 3 (William Paterson 8, Carthage 2) | 54 |
| Week 2 | Calvin (21) | 3 (Carthage 2, UW-Stevens Pt. 2) | 49 |
| Week 3 | Carthage (8) | 5 (Wooster 8, UW-Stevens Pt. 7, Buena Vista, Calvin) |
47 |
| Week 4 | Carthage (13) | 5 (Wooster 7, Calvin 3, Buena Vista, UW-Stevens Pt.) |
44 |
| Week 5 | Carthage (13) | 5 (Wooster 7, Calvin 3, Buena Vista, UW-Stevens Pt.) |
44 |
| Week 6 | Carthage (15) | 3 (Wooster 9, UW-Stevens Pt.) | 42 |
| Week 7 | Carthage (21) | 2 (Wooster 4) | 40 |
| Week 8 | Carthage (25) | 1 | 44 |
| Week 9 | Carthage (13) | 3 (Wilkes 8, Washington U. 4) | 44 |
| Week 10 | Carthage (15) | 2 (Wilkes 10) | 42 |
| Week 11 | Carthage (25) | 1 | 49 |
| Week 12 | Wooster (20) | 4 (Carthage 3, Ohio Northern, Wittenberg) | 45 |
| Week 13 | Carthage (10) | 5 (Wittenberg 9, Washington U. 3, Chicago 2, Ohio Northern) |
42 |
| Week 14 | Chciago (16) | 4 (Ohio Northern 4, Wooster 4, Wilkes) | 41 |
| Final | Catholic (25) | Catholic was No. 14 | 39 |
1999-2000 |
|||
| Pre | UW-Platteville (19) | 4 (Hampden-Sydney 3, William Paterson 2, Rowan) | 75 |
| Week 1 | UW-Platteville (19) | 3 (Hampden-Sydney 5, Rowan) | 69 |
| Week 2 | UW-Platteville (22) | 2 (Hampden-Sydney 3) | 62 |
| Week 3 | UW-Platteville (23) | 2 (Hampden-Sydney 2) | 49 |
| Week 4 | UW-Platteville (23) | 2 (Hampden-Sydney 2) | 46 |
| Week 5 | Hampden-Sydney (19) | 3 (UW-Platteville 5, UW-Eau Claire) | 48 |
| Week 6 | Hampden-Sydney (24) | 2 (UW-Platteville) | 44 |
| Week 7 | Hampden-Sydney (25) | 1 | 45 |
| Week 8 | Hampden-Sydney (25) | 1 | 46 |
| Week 9 | Hampden-Sydney (25) | 1 | 41 |
| Week 10 | Hampden-Sydney (25) | 1 | 39 |
| Week 11 | Hampden-Sydney (25) | 1 | 40 |
| Week 12 | Hampden-Sydney (25) | 1 | 39 |
| Week 13 | Calvin (14) | 2 (Hampden-Sydney 11) | 41 |
| Final | Calvin (25) | Calvin was No. 1 | 40 |