| Away | Home | Status | Links | |||
| Muhlenberg | 48 | No. 12 Gettysburg | 57 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| Sul Ross State | 71 | No. 15 Hardin-Simmons | 72 | Final | • * | BX P |
| Bryn Mawr | 29 | No. 17 Johns Hopkins | 87 | Final | • | BX |
| Mitchell | 74 | Daniel Webster | 60 | Final | • * | BX |
| Bay Path | 42 | Regis (Mass.) | 80 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| Becker | 56 | Elms | 67 | Final | • * | BX |
| Haverford | 37 | Ursinus | 55 | Final | • * | BX |
| Providence-Manitoba | 37 | North Central (Minn.) | 57 | Final | BX | |
| Belhaven | 63 | University of the Ozarks | 65 | Final | BX P | |
| Louisiana College | 61 | LeTourneau | 77 | Final | • * | BX |
| Howard Payne | 78 | McMurry | 68 | Final | BX | |
| Texas-Dallas | 55 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 60 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| East Texas Baptist | 63 | Texas-Tyler | 76 | Final | • * | BX |
| Suffolk | 44 | Johnson and Wales | 50 | Final | • * | BX RC P |
| Emerson | 84 | Fisher | 71 | Final | BX | |
| Swarthmore | 59 | Washington College | 37 | Final | • * | BX P |
| Connecticut College | 86 | Albertus Magnus | 52 | Final | • | BX P |
| Anna Maria | 46 | Western Connecticut | 78 | Final | • | BX |
| Valley Forge | 67 | Cedar Crest | 41 | Final | ||
| Lancaster Bible | 76 | St. Elizabeth | 59 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| Washington Adventist | 55 | Trinity (D.C.) | 43 | Final | BX | |
| Warren Wilson | 82 | Salem | 70 | Final | BX | |
| New Rochelle | 64 | John Jay | 66 | Final | • | BX |
| Wilson | 68 | Penn State-Berks | 105 | Final | • * | BX |
| Bryn Athyn | 72 | Penn State-Abington | 74 | Final | * | BX |
| Wheelock | 82 | Lesley | 34 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| St. John Fisher | 60 | Ithaca | 59 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| Occidental | 74 | Caltech | 54 | Final | • * | BX RC |
| La Verne | 68 | Chapman | 84 | Final | • * | BX RC |